Login

Cart

Your cart is empty
Newest Personalized Baby Gifts image

New Arrivals

Check out our newest Personalized Baby & Toddler Gifts! Please stop back often as we are adding more great products on a regular basis!

Sort by
Personalized Dog Bone Sherpa Blanket - 5 color choicesPersonalized Dog Bone Sherpa Blanket - 5 color choices
Personalized Dog Bone Sherpa Blanket - 5 color choices Sale price$74.99
Engraved My Dog Photo CubeEngraved My Dog Photo Cube
Engraved My Dog Photo Cube Sale price$34.98
Where Did My Dog Go? Personalized Family Search-and-Find BookWhere Did My Dog Go? Personalized Family Search-and-Find Book
Where Did My Dog Go? Personalized Family Search-and-Find Book Sale price$34.99
Personalized for Little Ones Gift CardPersonalized for Little Ones Gift Card
Personalized for Little Ones Gift Card Sale priceFrom $25.00
Have You a Cat in Heaven Wood Picture FrameHave You a Cat in Heaven Wood Picture Frame
Have You a Cat in Heaven Wood Picture Frame Sale price$35.99
A clear acrylic or glass teardrop-shaped memorial award plaque engraved with the text 'Forever in Our Hearts', two paw prints, the name 'BELLA', and the years '2014' and '2023'.A clear acrylic pet memorial plaque engraved with 'Forever in Our Hearts', two paw prints, the name 'BELLA', and the years '2014' and '2023' with a heart between them, shown on a wooden surface with a softly blurred background.
Forever In Our Hearts Pet Memorial Tear Keepsake Sale price$23.98
Personalized Best Dog Ever Oval Glass OrnamentPersonalized Best Dog Ever Oval Glass Ornament
Personalized Best Dog Ever Oval Glass Ornament Sale price$19.98
Wooden photo frame with 'In Memory of Charlie' engraving, featuring a dog holding a ball.Two women sitting on a couch with a framed photo of a dog and text 'Memory of CHARLIE'.
Personalized In Memory of Pet Wooden Picture Frame Sale price$35.99
Book cover of 'Oscar Across the Rainbow Bridge' with a cat and rainbow design.Woman and child reading a book together on a couch
Personalized Rainbow Bridge Pet Memorial Book – A Keepsake Story for Cats Sale price$29.99
Beige photo album with a picture of a golden retriever and text 'Best Friends are the ones with paws' and 'Bella'.Book with a cat photo and text 'Best Friends are the ones with paws' on a wooden surface.
Engraved Best Friends Are the Ones with Paws Personalized Leatherette Photo Album for Pets Sale price$34.99
Decorative stone with 'Bella's Garden' text and colorful floral design on a white backgroundTwo women holding a decorative garden stone with 'Bella's Garden' branding outdoors.
Personalized Pet Paw Print Flower Garden Stone Sale price$49.99
White ceramic jar with a lid featuring a picture of a dog on a grassy backgroundTwo women holding a white jar with a photo of a dog on it, one woman appears to be crying.
Custom Photo Ceramic Pet Urn Sale price$34.98
Wooden pet urn with engraved text 'Forever in Our Hearts Lucky 2001-2013' on a white backgroundWoman receiving a pet urn with 'Lucky' engraved, showing emotional reaction.
Engraved Wooden Memorial Pet Urn Sale price$59.98
Clear glass ornament with engraved text and paw prints, hanging on a Christmas tree branch.Clear glass ornament with gold string, measurements, and additional information on a white background
Engraved Pet Memorial Suncatcher Sale price$27.53
Wooden robot puzzle with 'Andrew' on a white backgroundBaby playing with robot puzzle
Wooden Puzzle Robot – Personalized Engraved Handmade Wooden Name Puzzle Sale price$29.90
Children's book titled 'Thank you, Lord, for Everything' with a bear character on the cover.Woman and child reading a book together in a cozy indoor setting
Thank You, Lord, For Everything Personalized Book Sale price$29.99
New Baby Birth Details Glass Picture Frame - Personalized
New Baby Birth Details Glass Picture Frame - Personalized Sale price$37.99
Wooden Picture Frame with Baby Elephant and Custom Messages - Personalized
Wooden Picture Frame with Baby Elephant and Custom Messages - Personalized Sale price$34.99
First Birthday Engraved Wooden Picture Frame - Personalized
First Birthday Engraved Wooden Picture Frame - Personalized Sale price$34.99
First Birthday Engraved Glass Picture Frame - Personalized
First Birthday Engraved Glass Picture Frame - Personalized Sale price$36.00
Baptism Sherpa Baby Blanket - PersonalizedBaptism Sherpa Baby Blanket - Personalized
Baptism Sherpa Baby Blanket - Personalized Sale price$52.99
Heart Sherpa Baby Blanket - PersonalizedHeart Sherpa Baby Blanket - Personalized
Heart Sherpa Baby Blanket - Personalized Sale price$52.99
Floral Sherpa Baby Blanket - PersonalizedFloral Sherpa Baby Blanket - Personalized
Floral Sherpa Baby Blanket - Personalized Sale price$52.99
You are Loved Sherpa Baby Blanket - PersonalizedYou are Loved Sherpa Baby Blanket - Personalized
You are Loved Sherpa Baby Blanket - Personalized Sale price$52.99
Sweet Baby Rainbow Night Light - PersonalizedSweet Baby Rainbow Night Light - Personalized
Sweet Baby Rainbow Night Light - Personalized Sale price$26.00
So Very Loved Baby Night Light - PersonalizedSo Very Loved Baby Night Light - Personalized
So Very Loved Baby Night Light - Personalized Sale price$26.00
Sweet Dreams Baby Night Light - PersonalizedSweet Dreams Baby Night Light - Personalized
Sweet Dreams Baby Night Light - Personalized Sale price$26.00
Adventure Baby Night Light - PersonalizedAdventure Baby Night Light - Personalized
Adventure Baby Night Light - Personalized Sale price$26.00
Baby Boy's First (1st) Birthday Personalized Board BookBaby Boy's First (1st) Birthday Personalized Board Book
Baby Boy's First (1st) Birthday Personalized Board Book Sale price$29.99
Baby Girl's First (1st) Birthday Personalized Board BookBaby Girl's First (1st) Birthday Personalized Board Book
Baby Girl's First (1st) Birthday Personalized Board Book Sale price$29.99
My Very Own Dinosaurs Personalized BookMy Very Own Dinosaurs Personalized Book
My Very Own Dinosaurs Personalized Book Sale price$34.99
Handmade Wooden Animal Puzzle - Bunny Rabbit - Personalized - Montessori Toy - Pic 1Handmade Wooden Animal Puzzle - Bunny Rabbit - Personalized - Montessori Toy - Pic 2
Handmade Personalized Bunny Rabbit Wooden Puzzle | Montessori Baby Gift Sale price$29.90
Super Hero Personalized Growth Chart
Super Kid Personalized Growth Chart | Fun & Inspiring Wall Décor Sale price$29.99
Owl Personalized Growth Chart
Gingham Owl Personalized Growth Chart | Whimsical Nursery Decor Sale price$29.99
Dinosaur Personalized Growth Chart
Dinosaur Personalized Growth Chart | Roaring Fun Nursery Gift Sale price$29.99
Vehicles Personalized Growth Chart
Things That Go Personalized Growth Chart | Perfect for Little Explorers Sale price$29.99
Outer Space Personalized Growth Chart
Outer Space Personalized Growth Chart | Blast Off with Growth! Sale price$29.99
Butterfly Personalized Growth Chart
Butterflies Personalized Growth Chart | All-a-Flutter Delight Sale price$29.99
Sports Personalized Growth Chart
Kick, Score, Run Personalized Growth Chart | For Little Athletes Sale price$29.99
Dreamy Day Personalized Growth Chart
Dreamy Day Personalized Growth Chart | Sweet Pastel Nursery Art Sale price$29.99
My Very Own Name Personalized Growth Chart
My Very Own Name Personalized Growth Chart | Celebrate Every Inch Sale price$29.99
Love is in the Air Personalized Growth Chart
Love Is in the Air Personalized Growth Chart | Sweet Nursery Decor Sale price$29.99
All Natural Wooden Teether - Cell Phone - Handmade Wooden Baby Toy Teether pic1All Natural Wooden Teether - Cell Phone - Handmade Wooden Baby Toy
Personalized Wooden Baby Teether | Handmade Natural Cell Phone Toy Sale price$27.90
Handmade All-Natural Wooden Toy Car for Babies and Toddlers - Personalized - pic1Handmade All-Natural Wooden Toy Car for Babies and Toddlers - Personalized - pic2
Handmade All-Natural Personalized Wooden Toy Car Sale price$21.00
Personalized All-Natural Wooden Baby Rattle - Christian Fish - Handmade Wooden Baby Toy pic1Personalized All-Natural Wooden Baby Rattle - Christian Fish - Handmade Wooden Baby Toy pic2
Christian Fish Wooden Baby Rattle | Handmade & Personalized Gift Sale price$27.90
All-Natural Handmade Personalized Wooden Baby Rattle pic1All-Natural Handmade Personalized Wooden Baby Rattle pic2
Handmade Personalized Wooden Baby Rattle | Natural Baby Gift Sale price$27.90
Personalized All Natural Wooden Baby Rattle - Three Rings - Handmade Toy pic1Three Rings Personalized Wooden Baby Rattle | Handmade Natural Toy
Three Rings Personalized Wooden Baby Rattle | Handmade Natural Toy Sale price$27.90
Baby's First Easter Personalized Book pic1Baby's First Easter Personalized Book
My First Easter Egg Hunt | Personalized Baby Board Book Sale price$29.99